So as I was scrolling through my Twitter feed today, I ran across a link to this article by Fonda Lee: The Case for YA Science Fiction. Read the post before you continue. I’ll wait…
…
…
…
…
…
Okay. So, the gist of the post is that YA Fantasy novels have been selling like crazy. There are several big name authors, including those mentioned in Lee’s post and many others. I can tell you right now I’ve read most of the books put out by all of those authors in the YA Fantasy genre. And so have millions of others. They may not be as popular as dystopians, and they certainly don’t get as many movie deals. But they move a lot of dead trees and digital trees. I’ve been blogging and writing long enough to remember four or five rounds of “Will Science Fiction be the next big thing in YA?” And the answer was always no. There would be upticks and uptrends. Several fantastic books would come out in a short period. But nothing would ever really break into the big money or sales the way YA Fantasy often does. It wouldn’t be blasted all over the blogosphere, or the writers forums, or the tip top of the best sellers lists. Which is too bad, because science fiction has a lot of value to add to YA as a category, and it can address issues and do so in ways not available to other genres.
Lee mentions several notable YA SF novels that take on current events and other contemporary issues that are ripe for exploration: MT Anderson’s Feed is a fantastic look at the way social media has been taken over by advertisers looking to build monetizable consumer profiles, and the ending, without spoilers, takes a look at just how far they go in valuing those profiles over the actual humans behind them. She mentions House of the Scorpion, which I didn’t care for, but which is still a very good novel on the subject of cloning. Scott Westerfeld never gets credit for his amazing additions to the YA SF canon, with the steampunk Leviathan series and the dystopian Uglies series.
YA SF has a lot of unmined treasure to be found, and maybe it will have to focus a bit on near-future SF for awhile, to whet the appetite of YA readers. Some of the hard SF tropes Lee discusses in her post kinda bore me, honestly. And as a writer I feel like saying “it’s magic” is popular because it’s simpler. There’s always a huge debate in adult SFF about whether the worldbuiding or science details really add enough to the story compared to the narrative effects of the speculative elements. The social issues we are having as a world today are incredibly accessible fruit for a YA SF novel to harvest. Social media, AI/big data, consumer profiles, technology in education.
I mean, I know 8-year-olds whose schools give out tablets to every student to take advantage of what tech in the classroom can offer. My high school was getting SmartBoards in every classroom just a year after I left in the late 2000s. But you never see any of this in YA books. They often feel set no later than my sophomore year of high school given the technology and social issues involved. Being a teenager will always be being a teenager, but the 80s and early 90s are waaaaaaaaaaaaayyy different than what young adults encounter in their general environment today. Of course, to be SF you can’t just upgrade the setting to the present day.
You have to extrapolate out quite a bit further than that. But given the environment today’s teens are living in, doing so while keeping the story interesting and relatable is so easy. What’s the next big advance in social media? How will smart houses/the internet of things impact the lives of young adults for better or worse? How will the focus of education change as more and more things that you used to have to do in your head or learn by rote are made trivial by computers? What social or political trends are emerging that might have big consequences in the lives of future teenagers? How could an author explore those more intensely with element of science fiction than they could with a contemporary novel?
I definitely share Lee’s sense that YA “science fiction” grabs trappings to stand out from the crowd rather than being rooted inherently in the tropes of the genre. It’s not uncommon for YA in general to play this game with various genre outfits, but sci-fi often seems the hardest hit. That’s not a criticism of those books, but just pointing out it might give readers, writers, and publishers a false image of what SF really is and how YA can benefit from incorporating more of it.
As a reader, I’ve always dabbled in both the YA and Adult book cases. And from that perspective, I wonder if the flavor of YA much of SF might be telling SF readers, teenaged or otherwise, that it’s just not the book(s) for them.
As a writer, I have lots of novel ideas that are YA and SF, and I’d like to explore them,and maybe even publish some of them one day. But I do have to wonder, given the wide variety of stories building in my head, am I taking a risk with my career by writing in such a threadbare genre? Perhaps others with similar plot ideas feel the same, and that’s why they aren’t submitting these ideas(books) to publishers?